The room
The two chefs met on the line at Roberta's in 2018; Kelley later cooked at Aska and Per Se, Grossman at Gage & Tollner and Foul Witch. They took the space that Colonie held for more than a decade because it had the wood and brick they wanted. The light is low. The long front bar is mostly for walk-ins, and the counter at the back serves as a chef's table, where Kelley and Grossman work.
What to order
The prawn pot pie, which Grub Street calls the hero dish, is a made-to-order prawn bisque with parsnip and pearl onion under pastry seasoned with Espelette; the menu marks it as limited. Start with trout mousse on sourdough with smoked trout roe. Mariah Neston bakes the bread and desserts, among them a biscuit tortoni of almond semifreddo on amaretti.
At a glance
- Hours: Tuesday to Sunday, 5 to 10 p.m.
- Reservations: On Resy; the front bar is largely held for walk-ins